Nightcap at York on Lilydale, Mount Evelyn, Australia - 1
Nightcap at York on Lilydale, Mount Evelyn, Australia - 2
Nightcap at York on Lilydale, Mount Evelyn, Australia - 3
Mount Evelyn, Australia4 starsCard
8.5 · 1,666 reviews

Nightcap at York on Lilydale

Restaurant, Bars, and Outdoor Pool - Indulge in a culinary journey at our restaurant, unwind at the bars, and soak up the sun by the outdoor swimming pool amidst serene bushland.

Family-Friendly Amenities - Enjoy a family bistro with tempting menu options, indoor and outdoor children's playgrounds, and a sports bar for social gatherings, ensuring a delightful stay for guests of all ages.

Leisure and Activities - Stay active with a tennis court on-site, perfect for sports enthusiasts looking to engage in a friendly match or two.

Experience the tranquility of York On Lilydale with its array of amenities, family-friendly atmosphere, and leisure options. Book now for an unforgettable stay!

4Sleeps
1Bedrooms
1Bathrooms
30Area
1Min nights

Amenities

Air conditioningBarBreakfastHeatingLuggage storageParkingPoolRestaurantRoom serviceWheelchair accessibleWi-Fi

Tags

Location

Mount Evelyn, Australia

Hotel guest reviews

8.5Very good · based on 1,666 reviews

AI summaryOverall positive: many guests would rebook and praised comfort, cleanliness and friendly staff, though a subset experienced heating/noise issues that limited enjoyment for those stays.

  • Cleanliness9.2
    Repeatedly praised across reviews — described as 'beautiful and clean', 'super clean and tidy', 'very clean' and 'clean comfortable', indicating a consistently high standard of housekeeping.
  • Service8.9
    Generally positive: staff described as attentive, helpful and well organised with good reception/security support; isolated reports of rudeness and some room-service hiccups.
  • Location9.0
    Strong location feedback: easy access to club facilities, on-site bottle shop and restaurant, plenty of parking and convenient for local visits.
  • Room7.8
    Mixed signals: many guests praised spacious rooms, comfy beds and good showers, but several mentions of cold rooms/heater problems, noisy AC, a dated bathroom and a too-soft mattress.
  • Amenities8.3
    Generally useful amenities (Netflix, free water/tea/coffee bottles, parking, spa) but some issues reported — spa jets not working, no in-room coffee/kitchen/toaster for longer stays and occasional maintenance noises.
  • Value for money7.6
    Mixed value perceptions: positive comments about food and comfortable rooms but negatives around extra costs (e.g. $37 for two drinks) and a $100 bond dispute dampening perceived value.
  • Food and drink8.7
    Food generally well rated — guests recommended dinner and pies and called meals delicious; a few service delivery issues (forgotten dessert, ordering difficulties) noted.

What guests liked

Consistently clean roomsComfortable beds and spacious roomsHelpful and attentive staff (mostly)Good location with easy parking and on-site amenitiesNice showers and lake/view rooms mentionedComplimentary water/tea/coffee bottles and NetflixDelicious on-site meals (meat pie highlight)Security/reception support for late check-in

What could be better

Heating issues — rooms remarked as cold; heater/AC problemsNoisy AC and occasional dripping/heating-unit noiseSpa jets not workingDated bathroom in some rooms and mattress softness complaintsNo in-room kitchen/coffee/toaster for longer staysRoom service ordering problems and forgotten itemsPerceived poor value for some (expensive drinks, bond issues)Isolated report of rude staff member

Latest reviews

AUMichelleTravelled solo · Oct 3010

Clean, large, airy room, large bathroom. Fantastic restaurant with delicious breakfast.

N/A

AUAlexandraTravelled with a group · Oct 259.0
Lovely, clean and easy to navigate with friendly staff.

Room was very clean and had all the fixings of a good hotel room. The beds were comfortable and the vew from the room was nice. Plenty of fluffy towels and amenities. Liked it!

The parking was a bit average. There are these large dips in front of the spots and some spots have stumps at the top, which are not easy to see.

GBAlisonTravelled with family · Oct 199.0
Very good

Friendly and clean

Old fashioned bathroom

AUEamonnTravelled with a group · Oct 189.0
Woke up to Monet pond views.

Rooms were great and staff very friendly and helpful.

It would be good to see a little love for the tennis court and basketball ring.

AUWhitworthTravelled with a group · Oct 147.0

The staff where so friendly

Didn't get the room I paid for, booking.com fault through 3rd party booking apparently Still have no reply on refund for room with a bath that we didn't get and paid $100 extra

AUDenitaTravelled as a couple · Oct 139.0
Excellent home base for exploring amd visiting

Excellent corner room upstairs with lovely view over garden and lake. Quiet spot and screen door to leave open and enjoy the sounds of birds and frogs in the evening. Hot shower, comfy bed and easy access to restaurant.

A little more attention to detail in the bathroom- some hairs in the tub on arrival and small pieces of rubbish were able to be seen on the floor.

You might also like

All stays in Mount Evelyn
Lilydale, Australia4 starsCard
8.7 · 621 reviews

Foothills

3 Guests1 Bedroom1 Bathroom2 m²14:00 — 10:00
Air conditioningBreakfastHeatingParkingTVWheelchair accessibleWi-Fi+1
FamilyTennisWork
$119.20/ night
Kalorama, Australia4 starsCard
8.0 · 910 reviews

Panorama Retreat & Resort

5 Guests1 Bedroom1 Bathroom12 m²14:00 — 10:00
Air conditioningGymHeatingLuggage storageParkingPoolWi-Fi
TennisWork
$111.58/ night
Kalorama, Australia4 starsCard
8.5 · 314 reviews

Rustic Refuge Guesthouse

2 Guests1 Bedroom1 Bathroom10 m²13:30 — 11:30
Air conditioningBreakfastHeatingHot tubKitchenParkingTV+2
Adults onlyHiking
$102.24/ night
Mount Dandenong, Australia5 starsCard

Arnica Views Summit Retreat

4 Guests1 Bedroom1 Bathroom50 m²15:00 — 11:00
Air conditioningBreakfastDryerHeatingKitchenParkingSpa+2
Family
$284.01/ night
Mount Dandenong, Australia4 starsCard
9.0 · 137 reviews

Observatory Cottages

8 Guests1 Bedroom1 Bathroom37 m²15:00 — 10:00
Air conditioningBreakfastFireplaceHeatingKitchenParkingSpa+3
$292.06/ night
Mount Dandenong, Australia5 starsCard
9.4 · 183 reviews

Linden Gardens Rainforest Retreat

2 Guests1 Bedroom1 Bathroom60 m²14:00 — 11:00
Air conditioningBarBreakfastHeatingHot tubKitchenLuggage storage+5
$274.18/ night
Mount Dandenong, Australia4 starsCard
8.2 · 145 reviews

Tudor Cottages

2 Guests1 Bedroom1 Bathroom50 m²14:00 — 11:00
Air conditioningBreakfastFireplaceHeatingKitchenParkingSpa+3
FishingHikingHorses
$289.22/ night
Lilydale, Australia4 starsCard
9.0 · 1,606 reviews

Yarra Valley Motel

5 Guests1 Bedroom1 Bathroom25 m²14:00 — 10:00
Air conditioningHeatingLuggage storageParkingWheelchair accessibleWi-Fi
Family
$163.45/ night